The crunch is a vastly overrated ab exercise.
Crunches shorten the rectus abdominis (“six pack”) muscles, and don’t strengthen the entire abdominal region.
A bodybuilder doing partial-range biceps curls might be laughed out of the gym, but it’s perfectly acceptable to do partial-range sit-ups.
Partial-range movements are usually restricted for pre-fatiguing a muscle or to work on a weak spot in a full-range motion exercise by inducing a “functional isometric contraction” at a specific joint angle.
That’s why a quality power rack in a gym always has two sets of pins.
San Diego State University (in a study led by Peter Francis, Ph.D.) rated ab exercises on EMG machines.
From most effective to least effective for the rectus abdominus, the ratings were …
248 – elbow-to-opposite-knee “bicycles”
212 – hanging knee raises
139 – crunches on an exercise ball
129 – vertical leg crunches
127 – torso-track machine exercises
119 – long-arm crunches
109 – reverse crunches
107 – crunches with a heel push
105 – ab roller exercises
100 – bridges with weight on the elbows
100 – traditional crunches
092 – exercise tubing pulls
021 – ab rocker exercises
From most effective to least effective for the abdominal oblique muscles, the ratings were …
310 – hanging knee raises
290 – elbow-to-opposite-knee “bicycles”
240 – reverse crunches
230 – bridges with weight on the elbows
216 – vertical-leg crunches
147 – crunches on an exercise ball
145 – torso-track machine exercises
126 – crunches with a heel push
118 – long-arm crunches
101 – ab roller exercises
100 – traditional crunches
077 – exercise tubing pulls
074 – ab rocker
My belief in “all-or-nothing” muscle contraction was shattered when I saw a belly-dancer place eight quarters on her abdomen and roll any quarter or combination of quarters up and down her midsection on request.
She also used her talented ab muscles to fold dollar bills into halves, quarters, and eighths.
Remember – and if you’re a regular reader of Atom’s Blog, you already know this – the primary cause of central obesity (belly fat) is GASEOUS PRESSURIZATION, mostly due to carbon dioxide.
I’ve been telling people about carbon dioxide’s role in weight gain since the 1970s, and scientists are just starting to get a clue about it this year with headlines like …
“Scientists Discover Link Between Carbon Dioxide and Obesity”
“High CO2 Levels Are Making People Fat, Says New Study”
“Blame the Smog For Your Weight Gain”
“Could Air Pollution Be Making Us Fat?”
“Does Carbonated Water Cause Weight Gain?”
Etc.
'Crunches Suck When It Comes to Ab Exercises' have 4 comments
December 1, 2012 @ 9:37 am Michael
how do dead lifts rate as an abdominal exercise?
December 2, 2012 @ 12:59 am atomb
San Diego State University didn’t rate deadlifts, but they’re an OK ab exercise.
MRI analysis shows 21 muscles are recruited in a standard deadlift, including the rectus abdominis muscles, external obliques, and internal obliques.
February 12, 2013 @ 3:56 pm Tracy
this is really helpful thank you. could anyone help me out with this. there is a workout routine which is in use with a great deal of people now. i’ve looked around a lot sites to see if this actually works since people say it will. everyone has positive things to say on the program and also I have noticed results from it as i have been using it for Two weeks as of now. could somebody let me know what do you think of it? below is a review on it. should i keep on this regime as it is working out seriously well.
February 12, 2013 @ 4:28 pm atomb
All hat and no cattle, Tracy. But if it’s working for you, be my guest. :)